Five Issues Keeping Credit Union Executives Up at Night
Created by Steven J. Berkowitz | Research Assistant: Claude AI
As of May 20, 2026
Subscribe to my newsletter and articles on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/newsletters/7392939880244355072/
or my free Substack:
AI-Powered Fraud Has Crossed a Threshold
The Trend
Fraud powered by artificial intelligence has moved from a future risk to a present crisis. Seven in ten financial institutions reported major increases in fraud in 2025, driven by organized fraud rings and an 1,100% surge in the use of AI, deepfakes, and synthetic identities by criminal actors. The numbers are specific and sobering: credit unions observed a 55% increase in remote-access trojan-enabled fraud in 2025, a category accounting for 15% of all credit union fraud, barely on the radar two years ago. America’s Credit Unions
The threat has become personal for members. Fraudsters use synthetic voices to bypass voice-based authentication systems. They create AI-generated videos to impersonate executives during video conference calls. A member might receive a phone call from someone who sounds exactly like their loan officer requesting immediate fund transfers. America’s Credit Unions
Why It Matters
Cybersecurity, including fraud, ranked as the top concern for the second consecutive year among credit union executives, surpassing the next-highest concern, fintech competition, by 22 percentage points. In the past year, 77% of respondents experienced at least one cybersecurity incident at their institution. Wipfli LLP
Deloitte’s Center for Financial Services predicts that generative AI could enable fraud losses to reach $40 billion in the United States by 2027, up from $12.3 billion in 2023. For a cooperative built on member trust, each successful attack carries consequences that extend beyond the financial loss itself. Trust, once broken, takes years to rebuild. And regulators are paying close attention. The NCUA’s 2026 supervisory priorities emphasize payment system security and fraud risk governance, reflecting the regulator’s awareness that these pressures are intensifying across the system. The Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council sunset its Cybersecurity Assessment Tool in August 2025, directing institutions toward frameworks such as NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 and CISA performance goals. America’s Credit Unions America’s Credit Unions
Actions to Consider
Deploy real-time voice authentication. Deepfake detection systems that score calls passively in real time without adding friction can cut average authentication time by 58 seconds per call while filtering synthetic voices before they reach frontline staff. Evaluate vendors now as this capability is no longer optional.
Treat staff as your first line of defense. Train branch, call center, and operations staff on AI-driven social engineering techniques. AI attacks require human defenders who can recognize behavioral anomalies that technology alone may miss.
Build a formal AI incident response plan. Map out what your credit union does in the first 60 minutes of a deepfake or account takeover event. Document containment steps, member notification protocols, and regulatory reporting timelines. Examiners will ask for this.
AI Deployment Is Running Ahead of AI Governance
The Trend
Credit unions are deploying AI tools at speed. The problem is that governance frameworks are not keeping pace. While two-thirds of credit unions are actively implementing AI, only 16% report having an enterprise-wide AI roadmap with governance and measurable business impact. CUToday
Regulators have noticed this gap. The NCUA published its Artificial Intelligence Compliance Plan in September 2025, updated its AI resource hub in December 2025, and reinforced a risk-focused examination approach in its January 2026 Supervisory Priorities letter. The real message is that NCUA will evaluate AI systems using regulatory frameworks already in place, including BSA/AML, fair lending, vendor management, and enterprise risk management. Advisorlabs
The stakes are high and specific: under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and Regulation B, credit unions must be able to provide specific reasons for adverse actions. If an AI system cannot explain why it recommended denying a loan or flagging a transaction, a compliance problem exists right now, not when NCUA publishes future guidance.
Resource: NCUA — https://ncua.gov/regulation-supervision/regulatory-compliance-resources/artificial-intelligence-ai
Why It Matters
Examiners are preparing to evaluate AI systems before they arrive at your institution. The NCUA’s 2026–2030 Strategic Plan makes AI its own objective, with concrete deliverables including a large language model pilot, an AI steering committee, an AI roadmap with milestones, and an updated data-driven risk model all by December 31, 2026. The practical implication is that examiners will start using AI-assisted tools to scope examinations before they walk in the door. The 5300 call report data every credit union files quarterly becomes the first read on where examiners spend their time. CU Exam Solutions
Meanwhile, the competitive stakes from inaction are significant. NACUSO President and CEO Randy Salser has stated that innovation requires capital, and credit unions need to be able to invest and have a seat at the table in shaping these technologies. The current statutory CUSO investment cap of 1% of assets may soon become a major deterrent to remaining competitive as AI and fintech investment becomes more essential. CUToday
Actions to Consider
Build an AI inventory before examiners do. Catalog every AI tool in use across the organization from fraud detection to chatbots to credit decisioning. Classify each by level of member impact. This inventory becomes the foundation of your compliance posture.
Establish board-level AI oversight. Assign AI governance as a standing board agenda item. Document the board’s understanding of AI risk, tolerance thresholds, and review cadence. Regulators expect this and will look for evidence of it.
Audit every AI vendor relationship. Credit unions face distinct challenges when partnering with AI companies that extend beyond traditional third-party vendor management, including understanding algorithmic decision-making processes, ensuring fair lending compliance, protecting member data privacy, maintaining operational resilience, and managing model risk. Map each vendor to existing third-party risk frameworks and close documentation gaps now. NCUA
Economic Turbulence Is Squeezing Both Sides of the Balance Sheet
The Trend
The tariff environment has introduced a degree of economic uncertainty that few credit union balance sheets were built to absorb. Auto tariffs are expected to push new car prices up 10–15%, meaning either fewer loans originated or higher-balance loans to members under more financial stress. Either scenario pressures loan quality in the second half of 2026. Blastpoint
Consumer sentiment has reached a critical level. The Index of Consumer Sentiment declined steadily throughout 2025 and into 2026. The reading of 55 in March 2026 was even lower than the peak days of the COVID pandemic and signals genuine household anxiety rather than routine fluctuation. Creditunions
Source: Callahan & Associates — https://creditunions.com/blogs/5-takeaways-from-trendwatch/
Why It Matters
The margin picture is shifting in real time. Loan origination economics are getting tighter, with CRE origination rates down 70 basis points year over year and 135 basis points from peak levels. On the deposit side, cost relief is waning. DCG
A specific pressure point looms on the deposit side: members who locked 12-month CDs at 4.5–5%+ APY in 2024–2025 are reaching maturity throughout 2026, a wall of member decision points. Credit unions that know who holds those certificates and proactively engage will retain them. The ones running blind will wake up to outflows. Blastpoint
Meanwhile, delinquency ratios came in at 0.81% in Q1 2026, with net charge-offs at 0.84%, for a combined ratio of 1.65%. These numbers are better than the fourth quarter of 2025 but remain higher than pre-pandemic norms. Creditunions
Actions to Consider
Run scenario-specific stress tests today. Model the impact of auto tariff pass-through on your indirect and direct auto portfolio. Understand your delinquency exposure if unemployment rises to 4.6% as projected. Present results to your board with concrete response options.
Activate certificate maturity outreach now. Identify every member with a maturing certificate in the next six months. Build a personalized retention campaign that leads with financial counseling, not rate competition. Members who feel seen stay.
Shift from rate-driven deposit strategy to relationship-driven deposit strategy. The most effective credit unions use behavioral and transactional data to understand deposit behavior, predict needs, and capture balances, answering questions that rate increases never can: which members have funds parked elsewhere, and who is ready for balance migration with the right product. Clutch
The Leadership Pipeline Has a Structural Crack
The Trend
The retirement wave among Baby Boomer credit union leaders has accelerated, and a new NCUA mandate has made the gap impossible to ignore. The NCUA’s succession planning rule went into effect on January 1, 2026, requiring formal, written succession plans for federally insured credit unions. Even so, through its own analysis, NCUA found that as of 2023, approximately one in four credit unions either lacked a succession plan or had one that was inadequate.
Compliance on paper does not solve the actual problem. Many institutions still lack viable leadership pipelines. While most report having succession plans, few have clearly identified “ready-now” successors.
Source: Zayla Partners — https://zayla.com/credit-union-succession-planning/
Why It Matters
Leadership gaps trigger mergers. The NCUA cited industry consolidation and the volume of Baby Boomer retirements as the two primary reasons for the new rule. When a credit union loses its CEO with no successor ready, the most common outcome is a merger, often at less-than-ideal terms, and the loss of a community institution.
Credit unions operate within compensation frameworks that limit their competitiveness for executive talent. Aging leadership and limited pipelines create succession risk. Regulatory pressure mandates documented succession plans. Compensation constraints and weak compensation philosophies limit talent attraction and retention. As a result, succession plans may be difficult to fully execute in practice, despite being formally in place. Zayla Partners
The challenge extends well beyond the C-suite. Long-tenured credit officers, compliance specialists, operations leads, and core systems architects carry institutional knowledge, such as credit judgment, regulatory relationships, operational muscle memory that exists nowhere in any documented system and cannot be reverse-engineered from data alone. Wolters Kluwer
Actions to Consider
Link succession planning to compensation strategy. Evaluate whether your current executive compensation structure, including Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans (SERPs), positions your credit union to attract and retain the leaders your next strategic plan requires. The two conversations belong together.
Expand your succession inventory beyond the C-suite. Map critical roles across compliance, lending, IT, and operations. For each, document: who could fill it, what development they need, and what institutional knowledge they carry that exists nowhere else.
Treat board succession with the same urgency as executive succession. Governance continuity matters. The NCUA rule requires newly appointed directors to gain working familiarity with the succession plan within six months of their appointment. Build director development programs that develop pipeline candidates before vacancies create urgency. CliftonLarsonAllen
Deposit Competition Has Become a Structural Problem, Not a Cyclical One
The Trend
The fight for core deposits has intensified beyond the rate cycle. Fintechs, megabanks, and digital-first platforms have conditioned members to expect high yields and frictionless experiences simultaneously. Nearly two-thirds of credit union executives now identify new member growth, operational efficiency, and deposit gathering as top concerns, with these “growth anxieties” escalating sharply over recent years. Traditional approaches including branch expansion, broad marketing campaigns, and incremental product updates are proving insufficient against competition from fintechs and megabanks. The Financial Brand
Why It Matters
With forecasted Federal Reserve rate cuts unclear for the remainder of 2026, credit union funding costs will remain elevated as competition for core deposits stays high. As a result, smaller institutions will continue to struggle to maintain profitability and will ultimately seek merger partners due to the pressure on net interest margins and the higher percentage of fixed regulatory costs to total costs when operating a small financial institution. Wilary Winn
The competitive pressure arrives from multiple directions at once. Loan growth can reduce margins, deposit competition is still intense, and acquisition costs continue to rise. The credit unions winning this battle are the ones that treat deposit strategy as a data and relationship problem, not a rate problem. CSI
Actions to Consider
Segment your deposit base by behavior, not product. Use your data to identify which members hold primary financial relationships with you versus which park occasional balances. Design retention strategies for each segment. The member who uses your checking account daily is a fundamentally different relationship than the one who opened a CD for the rate.
Invest in onboarding as a deposit retention strategy. The first 90 days of a new membership predict long-term deposit behavior more reliably than any subsequent campaign. Map your onboarding journey and remove every point of friction between account opening and first direct deposit.
Evaluate merger and partnership strategies proactively, not reactively. Inorganic strategies such as mergers and indirect lending continue to play a role for credit unions pursuing growth. Credit unions that approach merger conversations from a position of financial strength write better deals and protect their members more effectively than those who wait until the margin pressure becomes unbearable. CSI